The Fundamentals Defined Rather a lot Why Singapore Shares Struggled – Funding Moats

As individuals speak about how AI goes to kill these data-related corporations, I noticed this chart pop-up in one in all our inner discussions:

This can be a chart of the Straits Instances index from 2000 to 2026 (Inexperienced), overlay with the weighted common of earnings per share (EPS) – 12 months ahead (Orange) and taking one divide by the opposite (Cyan).

For those who take a look at the inexperienced line, you may see the Singapore fairness market begins going via that fairly difficult 1999 to 2003, the place we have now a US recession, Asian Monetary Disaster, Dot Com bust, SARS all stacked collectively. That to me nonetheless looks like essentially the most difficult part and at any time when individuals say “I don’t assume you may have many shitty stuff stacked collectively after one other..” I might consider this LOL.

Then we have now a reasonably good interval aided by how effectively China have been doing.

Since 2008, Singapore market haven’t gone any the place and solely made again to its excessive in 2025.

That’s 17 years.

I prefer to warning that the Straits Instances Index shouldn’t be complete return, which suggests it didn’t consider dividends however I believe even in case you add that, it nonetheless takes a very long time to return again.

I simply discover that completely different individuals have completely different frames when discussing a specific space similar to Singapore. Those that invested primarily in 2018 could have a greater expertise than those that have rather a lot invested in 2008. That is no completely different than speaking concerning the property market.

I might hear completely different sorts of morale when speaking to people who purchased their properties in 2013 verus 2018 someplace in 2020.

Your expertise is completely different.

Fundamentals clarify why the efficiency of a area is like that. It isn’t with out area.

Straits Instances Earnings Per Share Progress Versus Value.

The orange line reveals the 12 month ahead earnings per share estimate.

If we take the earnings per share forecast for the subsequent 12 months of every of the index elements and also you mixture them, you get a chart like this.

When you could marvel how correct are consensus ahead estimates there are optimistic to it.

1. If your enterprise was not doing effectively however seemingly doing higher as a result of what you stated within the quarter, ahead EPS will look higher. This could present everybody you’ll make extra earnings.
2. The present value of one thing is an mixture of FUTURE money flows, discounted with a hurdle fee. You might be at all times attempting to see how costly or low-cost one thing shouldn’t be about what it did within the PAST however the FUTURE.
3. Whereas we will say analysts and managers could be overly optimistic, viewing it in such a chart modify over time.

You’ll be able to go on the market and see how simple it’s to search out this information. We simply obtained entry to this not too way back. In case you are a shopper of Providend and finally like this publish after studying this, do electronic mail or message me and I can see if our Funding Workforce can do extra content material like this.

Okay, the pink field highlights a interval the place the earnings per share struggled. You understand that the orange EPS line strikes in an analogous method because the inexperienced line.

I might say if value is down, it signifies that the EPS goes to show down.

If value is up, it signifies the EPS goes to show up.

Not at all times however when seen over a 17-year interval you may see it.

The value is an mixture of future money flows and in hindsight future money flows of the Straits Instances was unstable, and went nowhere.

I believe you recognize the MSCI World did fairly effectively throughout this 2010 to 2020 interval of EPS wrestle so right here is the EPS of the MSCI World and MSCI Rising Market:

This chart reveals the EPS for MSCI World and Rising markets over a very long time body. We’ve extra information whether it is this. That is trailing earnings per share as an alternative of ahead, however you may see that when seen over a time collection, it form of issues much less.

The MSCI Worlds trailing EPS went via the identical rise and dips however earnings per share find yourself larger. In distinction, the trailing EPS of the MSCI Rising markets additionally went via the identical grind because the Straits occasions, and also you additionally know the efficiency of Rising Markets was lower than stellar over that interval.

So the place is the EPS of Straits Instances, MSCI World, Rising Markets going to go Kyith?

Beats me.

My job is to inform you that there’s elementary grounding to the efficiency of those stuff so that you could focus extra on the query: So does earnings per share, when seen over long term actually goes up?

Value Leads EPS

I used to say I’ll watch for the basics to point out me convincingly that the earnings are exhibiting up.

However that often doesn’t work that effectively.

I get confusion why the worth is working for no purpose.

Then I understand that value… is one of the best indicator of future efficiency. Not at all times, however the market constantly tries to cost in how it’s.

I highlighted a couple of pink bins and you’ll take a look at the inexperienced and the orange strains. Typically the inexperienced strains lead the orange strains, which signifies that value leads fundamentals.

For instance the worth begins going up in 2008 earlier than the EPS turns up. Its simpler to see on such a chart however in a day-to-day foundation with out such EPS chart, you be much more confused why the worth is rising!

There can be a variety of whipsaws although, and it’s because the market consistency tries to worth stuff.

Essentially the most bizarre one is the final pink field. You see an enormous run up of EPS, however the value (inexperienced line) like didn’t go anyplace. However in a way, the worth may point out that EPS progress goes to take some breather.

What we’re seeing the EPS is it appears to be heading larger.

Or is it going to enter a dump once more?

That could be a subject for an additional day however no less than now you may marvel extra concerning the fundamentals.

It additionally form of inform you that if EPS is mostly larger in the long run, I don’t assume value could be surpress for too lengthy.

What About Valuation?

The Cyan line takes the worth dividend by the ahead EPS and it reveals the valuation of the index at that time:

I drew strains to point out the historic valuation vary that the Straits Instances index that trades at, which is round 11 to 14 occasions the previous 17 years.

If we invert PE of 11 and 14 we get 9% and seven%.

We will take a look at this because the earnings yield of the Straits Instances if we make investments lengthy sufficient (maybe 15-25 years).

In a manner with out a lot EPS progress it doesn’t imply that you just don’t have returns. If we have now a very long time horizon, we will earn a sure yield. it s a query of if the vast majority of the businesses return the cash effectively to shareholders within the type of share buyback or dividends.

If many of the shares will not be shareholder pleasant (maybe just like the final 10 years) then having a superb earnings yield additionally doesn’t assist.

Generally, markets undergo their ebbs and flows and the market will get extra low-cost or costly. However there are generally causes for it.

We haven’t see the earnings per share leap to a better plateau for some time.

I’ve an extended chart utilizing the MSCI Singapore index, which is a extra concentrated index:

That is additionally ahead EPS, and you’ll see that apart two various things:

1. The place EPS was within the early Nineties and the way bonkers the EPS progress was from 2003 to 2008 relative to historical past.
2. That the MSCI World truly can commerce at a better valuation.

In a manner ought to we fear if the valuation based mostly on PE shouldn’t be low-cost?

It form of means:

1. The market have priced in good earnings.
2. If earnings surprises even larger than what’s priced in, the Straits Instances Index can transfer up.
3. If earnings disappoints extra, costs would wrestle.

The value of a basket of securities over the long run, is pushed by fundamentals and hopefully I confirmed you in at present’s quick train.

---

For those who like these items and wanna faucet into my cash mind, do be part of my Telegram channel.

I share what I come throughout in:

• particular person inventory investing
• wealth-building methods
• portfolio administration
• private finance, monetary independence.

I might additionally share a number of the ideas of wealth advisory, monetary planning and the business that I don’t wanna put out on the weblog.

Would in all probability share some life planning case research based mostly on the issues I hear or got here throughout as effectively.


Kyith is the Proprietor and Sole Author behind Funding Moats. Readers tune in to Funding Moats to study and construct stronger, firmer wealth foundations, methods to have a Passive funding technique, know extra about investing in REITs and the nuts and bolts of Lively Investing.
Readers additionally comply with Kyith to discover ways to plan effectively for Monetary Safety and Monetary Independence.
Kyith labored as an IT operations engineer from 2004 to 2019. At the moment, he works as a Senior Options Specialist in Price-only Wealth Advisory Agency Providend. All opinions on Funding Moats are his personal and doesn’t signify the views of Providend.
You’ll be able to view Kyith’s present portfolio right here, which makes use of his Free Google Inventory Portfolio Tracker.
His funding dealer of selection is Interactive Brokers, which permits him to put money into securities from completely different exchanges all around the world, at very low fee charges, with out custodian charges, close to spot forex charges.
You’ll be able to learn extra about Kyith right here.